
Some spoilers!!! This movie is awesome, so if you haven’t seen it, don’t read this!
This movie is one of the best explorations of mental illness and its slow encroachment I have ever seen. Or, as someone who is not mentally ill (knock on wood), it seems to be the most empathetic survey of the subject I can think of–perhaps a person with mental illness would disagree. Then again, psychotic breaks are probably impossible to really capture on film, so you can only gesture at some sort of underlying truthiness. Much like drug trips. Thankfully, though, in this film there are no scenes where the camera spins around and a character laughs wildly.
I really did not like the very end, which I will not spoil. But up until that point, I was with this movie 100%. It’s slow and strange and melancholy, and shot against the backdrop of some terrible Midwestern town in the middle of nowhere. Michael Shannon plays the main guy, Curtis, a regular working class dude with a nice family. The movie opens with him watching a truly epic storm roll in across the prairie his house is on the edge of. Shannon has a great face–he reminds me a little bit of Big Ed Hurley–and he turns it up to the sky and watches the great roiling clouds expressionlessly. But when the rain falls onto him, it’s viscous and yellow like motor oil. He marvels at this. Then it cuts to the next morning, unexplained.
So he starts having these awful, awful nightmares. He dreams the storm is coming again, and his beloved dog attacks him, and it’s so real, and when he wakes up his arm hurts for the rest of the day. And he then devotes his weekend to building an enclosure out back, to lock his dog in. He won’t explain himself to his wife, who wants to know what gives. “It just has to be this way for awhile” is all he’ll say. He dreams faceless people attack his car and drag away his little daughter. It starts being a little hard to tell when he’s dreaming and when he’s awake, because the dreams start off so normal.
Meanwhile, we learn that his little daughter is deaf, and that his wife, Jessica Chastain, has her heart set on cochlear implants. The movie has this very very subtle built-in critique of the American economic and health care systems. Like a scene where Chastain is being told “You’re lucky–your husband’s insurance is very very good. Most plans wouldn’t cover a cochlear implant,” cuts to the husband picking up a prescription for 3 sleeping pills. “That’ll be $47.” “What? Well what’s my copay?” “…that IS your copay.” Or he calls his doctor and tries to get a psychiatrist appointment with somebody local, which turns out to be impossible, and the phone call takes place while he’s filling up the gas tank, and you can vaguely hear the little clicker going up and up and up, filling up the tank with dollar bills. And you’re like “oh fuck, this dude’s going to lose his job, isn’t he”
It’s so good because this guy is not a talker. He says like 10 things in the whole movie. He struggles in silence, but he’s also sensitive. So he has a couple of these nightmares and then suddenly goes to the library and picks up all these books on mental illness. And you’re thinking, well, that’s jumping the gun a little bit right? But then several scenes later he goes to visit his mother, and we slowly come to understand that SHE had a schizophrenic break when he was a child, and has been in assisted living ever since. Slowly we realize that this guy has lived with this fear in the back of his mind for his whole life–that he might one day go crazy, and have to leave his family in every sense of the word, just like what happened to him as a boy. It’s his worst nightmare, coming true now. That’s why he doesn’t want to talk to his wife about it, that’s why he’s trying so hard to get medical help that isn’t really available to him. There’s this devastating scene where he goes to see a counselor and he’s all knowledgeable and prepared, he’s got a notepad and he’s like “of the 5 signs of schizophrenia I’ve manifested 2,” etc. etc., then he’s like “so I need to get this under control so I can continue taking care of my family” and the counselor’s like “I’m not a psychiatrist and I can’t prescribe you anything. But lets talk about your mother,” and she means well, but you can just FEEL how unhelpful it is, how much like treading water it is, like this guy needs serious meds, STAT, but somehow that network of help doesn’t fully exist for him, nor does the money.
His madness starts manifesting as this desire to build a super tricked-out storm shelter in the yard. There are all these subtly disturbing scenes where, like, the wife comes home while he’s got the backhoe tearing up their yard, and she makes a “WTF” gesture at the friend who’s helping him, and the friend, totally stone-faced and obviously disturbed himself, makes this very small, slow hand gesture, like, “I know.”
I really liked how the storm shelter was JUST NORMAL ENOUGH of a thing to do that its madness was actually horrifying. Everyone in his life understands that what he’s doing is not right, something’s “off” about it, but it’s just normal enough that they can kind of shrug at it. If he were running around naked cutting himself there would be no way to avoid it, but the storm shelter is like…well, that’s harmless right? Even though everyone’s worried about it.
Ugh and of course it just spirals from there. I really think Michael Shannon is kind of a tremendous actor. He does such excellent face work in this movie. Face twitching and crazy-eyes, but then also he conveys how hard he is working to contain the crazy. And all without speaking.
It’s so good, and sad, and frightening. The movie really gets into how out of control you’d feel, how embarrassed. How embarrassing it is to go to a doctor and say “I’m losing my mind.” To ask for help in that way. It made me think about all the raving screaming homeless people you see in your life. How they were probably all once living lives of at least somewhat/more stability, but they were just enough on the outskirts economically and socially that when their psychotic break happened there was just nothing to hold them or help them. No meds for them; no social support network that could take care of them. And now they wander the streets in rags, scaring pedestrians. How do they even survive the winter. And who were they, once?
Also what is “insanity,” etc. Julian Jaynes talks a lot about how in ancient times there wouldn’t have been a concept of schizophrenia, because hearing voices and having visions was totally normal back then (due to various neuroscience stuff I can’t really go into right now, but you should read his book). You’d be like “a crazy storm is coming!!!!! YOU’RE ALL GONNA DIE” and people would be like “oh shit REALLY?” instead of saying “what do you mean, you can’t know that, because science, also social normativity, you are acting not normal, we must institutionalize you, Foucault Foucault Foucault.” He points out that as a schizophrenic, what would really freak you out and make you start panicking and running around wouldn’t necessarily be your hallucinations, it would be the fact that NO ONE ELSE SAW THEM. How isolating and frustrating. Your visions feeling SO REAL to you, so so real, that even if you were able to say “this is not real,” part of you would just never be able to believe it. Like even as Michael Shannon is trying to get on meds because he knows he’s having a psychotic break, he’s ALSO mortgaging his home to pay for this insane storm shelter. He’s living in both realities. He knows he’s going crazy, and he also knows a biblical storm is coming to sweep all of humanity away. And honestly, who knows which is real?? How come sometimes a person has a vision of Jesus and it’s a miracle, but other times it means the person is going bonkers? Time and place, etc. There’s a really sad scene where he stops his car and watches this insane lightning storm, and actually we (the viewer) never know if this time it’s a real storm or not. He watches it and says “is anybody else seeing this?” and looks back at the car where his wife and daughter are asleep. He’s alone, and you can tell he doesn’t know if it’s really happening or not. Just a quiet moment of realizing how alone he is, how alone we all are. We all die alone.
Anyway, it’s a sad movie. I also really liked the music in it.