so many!
The movies that have legitimately scared me the most in my life, and that remain scary to me:
Night of the Hunter
Jaws
The Exorcist
The Shining
Night of the Living Dead
28 Days Later
Blair Witch, don't even front!
I love scary movies and have seen so many, but these are the ones that still give me the howling fantods, even after all these years/viewings.
I am not super susceptible to the terrors of the classic horror franchises like Friday the 13th/Freddy Krueger's Dream Warriors, but the first Halloween is pretty fucking incredible. DONALD PLESANCE
A great scary movie that doesn't twist my guts up but is still pretty creepy is SUSPIRIA

Best soundtrack EVER, thank you Goblin!!!!!
then there's this, which I haven't seen, but this trailer very effectively makes me want to:

"I saw a priest, who by hanging himself, opened the gates of hell"
Comments
Grizzly Man
The Body Snatchers 1993
But I read The Road and it definitely should be on this list if the movie can access even an inkling of what I felt whilst reading it
Body Snatchers 1993
MANIAC
HOLY TERROR or ALICE SWEET ALICE
"Alice was too old to play with dolls and too young to make love. Brook Shields as you've never seen her before. She was too beautiful to play with boys and too young to play with boys. So Alice began to play... with death."
TOO SCARY
I can't do a sex-murder-woman-hatred-mommy-issues movie these days, it's too real-world scary for me!!!
I guess night of the hunter is one but that's different
Totally true. To say nothing of Carrie, which is about, like, girls start menstruating and then ARE CAPABLE OF THE MOST POWERFUL EVIL ON EARTH, a.k.a. fucking but lets not just come right out and say that
I mean, I love that Carrie's rampage begins after she is literally drenched in blood (and the story begins with her beginning to menstruate). Lets just literalize this age-old terror shall we
The Sentinal
It is about a nice lady who moves into a fancy apartment. Her neighbor in the penthouse is a priest who has to stand guard at the gate of hell!!
"She went to a party with three dead murderers." "Doesn't everybody?"
"No one's lived in that apartment for three years."
"I swear to god I'll kill ya. I'll KILLYA!"
Carnival of Souls
This is about a beautiful lady who is a little addled after a car accident so she decides to move by herself to a different town and take up work as a church organist near an abandoned carnival.
I guess it is about the vulnerability that a beautiful lady has when she is single. I seem to watch a lot of this type of horror.... what am I, Zakk Peningten?
terrifying
Has a super top-shelf single lady dame who solves the mystery and is not afraid!!!
Also, have you guys ever read stories on the Internet that scared you? They're usually best (worst) late at night, when you're all alone on the computer.
Like Ted's Caving Page or creepypasta.
one of my favorite creepypasta stories
I haven't read scary on the internet but I've read millions of books that scared me.
Reading the Shining in middle school was the only time I've ever actually felt my hair stand on end
I can not watch Antichrist, though I too am intrigued. I like the creepy/disturbia scary as opposed to the "dick-cutting-off" gore splash scary
although I do love to watch a zombie pull somebody's guts out
"Could I have my robe, please?"
"Gee whiz, honey, it's torn to ribbons."
I like it when the little cat growls at her and she is offended, but when it runs away she laughs and shrugs her shoulders.
The descent is great. I like that mostly nothing happens. Like it is pretty much a climbing movie. But it is scary as freak!
Becko you would LOVE cat people, I can't believe you haven't seen it. So much good My Girl Friday type single lady stuff! That lead lady is AN ARCHITECT. Not an architect's secretary--AN ARCHITECT! And she's got a crush on the male architect whose girlfriend is secretly also a panther. And she saves his life with her brassy derring-do!
It is so incredible.
Then there is this AMAZING scene with a scary bus
"No, thank you, I'm a big girl now and I'm not afraid."
"Unfinished Sweet" by Alice Cooper. It's about candy and the dentist. Very scary!
"St. Vitus' dance on my molars tonight"
What's going to happen?
WHAT IS IN THAT CAVE?????!!
"It's just a movie."
http://web.archive.org/web/20050117173007/www.dougaustin.com/tlcaves/pdf/Thefearofdarkness.pdf