Rinde Eckert - Urban Integration
From September 7, 2007
Against the backdrop of city sounds, Eckert's choir clustered together on the steps of Pioneer Square. I positioned myself towards the back of the audience, in order to experience a melding of intentional and environmental sounds, to hear the boundaries of the performance, in its site-specific nature. On the Great Migration of Excellent Birds used a full range of choral methods, from the strong, simple round of the beginning and end, to the extended techniques of hissing, mumbling, chattering and tongue clicks that mark many contemporary vocal pieces, to the rich unison chants reminiscent of church musics (they even threw in some "Amens" for good measure). At several points, the choir was overwhelmed by the sounds of traffic, Max train announcements, random voices and urban rumble. This seemed to annoy some audience members, who shushed at the world to be quiet. Personally, I was intruigued by hearing those choral voices as another element in the chaos of downtown movement. It seemed to highlight the openness, vulnerability and inhumanity of the American urban center. There was an essential tension between the continuing unresponsive city and the Great Migration's celebration of collective force with its chants of "We are the excellent birds! Where? Here! When? Now!".
The performers flapping books and sheets of white paper created a beautifully mundane ballet. In ordinary clothes, they were distinguishable from the bystanders and passers-by only in their grouping and determination to sing together. This created a feeling of accessibility and ordinariness, and forced the question: "Why don't we do this more often?"
I imagined the piece being performed in a European city center, where the buildings would comfortingly surround, creating a contained space for voices to bounce back, where a plaza of cafes and sidewalks would cater to the human ambulatory experience of real bodies for which this piece seemed to be designed.
I also imagined a different piece in which, possibly at the exclusion of such a unified visual spectacle, the choir would integrate with the audience and the city, spreading out to absorb rather than confront, meshing into the buildings, people and traffic...
- posted by Seth Nehil
<< | Posted on September 7, 2007 at 2:42 PM | >>
DAILY ARCHIVE >>
I have always wanted to see/hear a public piece that seemed to be really made for the space it was in, urban noise, random people coming by, the whole thing. There are those great moments when the inadvertent combination of sounds is far greater than the potential in the original piece, performed as if ignorant of or fighting it's context. Accidental resonances seem especially beautiful because you know they will never be repeated. Dischord in the environment is merely an awkward moment that everyone gets to laugh at, like teenagers hanging out & trying to ask each other on a first date, flubbing it, but forgiving each other just for trying.
Posted by Justine @ September 7, 2007 5:05 PM
Visually, it was very interesting. Sound wise, the surrounding cacophony drowned out the majority of Mr. Eckert's non-amplified music, with the accordion section completely lost - unless you were standing close, which I was not, until the post-show Carlo Rossi drinking song, which was fun. Kind of wish I'd have been able to hear this piece in the Gerding Theater, which apparently was the site of the very first rehearsal.*
Also, I noticed that PICA was shooting archival video from only three angles. They missed at least two more. One should been from above, perhaps via a r/c helicopter or at least the roof of a nearby tall building. Another angle that would have been cool - behind the center section of the choir facing the crowd and occasionally focusing on Rinde, the accordions and choir director. Then again, maybe someone got footage like this?
*http://tinyurl.com/2nxg4y
Posted by Brian Feldman @ September 8, 2007 1:55 AM
Post a comment:
I have always wanted to see/hear a public piece that seemed to be really made for the space it was in, urban noise, random people coming by, the whole thing. There are those great moments when the inadvertent combination of sounds is far greater than the potential in the original piece, performed as if ignorant of or fighting it's context. Accidental resonances seem especially beautiful because you know they will never be repeated. Dischord in the environment is merely an awkward moment that everyone gets to laugh at, like teenagers hanging out & trying to ask each other on a first date, flubbing it, but forgiving each other just for trying.
Posted by Justine @ September 7, 2007 5:04 PM