House is the worst show on television, hands down.

| | Comments (14)

I say this in complete seriousness. For some reason, this spectacle of medical fraudery and debauchitude seems to have gained some amount of crazed popularity among the television-watching public. I don't know who this "public" thinks it is, but I have no doubt that it is completely devoid of self-respect.

My friend Tracy and I found ourselves accidentally watching an episode last weekend. In our defense, we had been studying for our upcoming boards exam, and had rewarded ourselves for our hard work by watching a little of the so-called "boob tube." As it turned out, "boob" was right (in the old-timey sense of the word, whereby the term now liberally applied to female mammary anatomy was used to imply "a foolish person." And how.)

Now, Tracy and I are relatively smart gals. Between us we are near to completion of eight years of medical school and have an additional 2 years of a pathology student fellowship under our collective belts. But at one point we turned to eachother while watching House M.D., and exclaimed, "What the hell is going on?" All our years of medical training had left us unprepared to follow the plot line of House, a show based around a jerk-hole "genius" and his rag-tag team of young sexy internal medicine "experts" who together solve really challenging medical cases in a matter of hours, all the while learning valuable lessons about the meaning of friendship. Or something.

The episode Tracy and I watched was the one where Dave Matthews is an idiot savant who has something wrong with his brain. What is it? How can we possibly figure it out? It must be some logic-defying puzzle that can only be unlocked by the brilliant mind of one Doctor House, Medical Doctor.

All I know is that at one point the sexy young medical team was performing a carotid angiogram (something they would not know how to do), and then the next moment they were doing an upper endoscopy on a completely awake Dave Matthews (which is something that only gastroenterologists do - on sedated patients). Ooh! Now they are in the lab diagnosing neurosyphillis. Now they are snooping around somebody's house. And oh, what are they up to now? They are drilling through Dave Matthew's skull to get multiple brain biopsies!! I did not realize that in addition to being board-certified in Internal Medicine, the rag-tag team had also apparently completed a 7-year Neurosurgery residency!

Diagnosis after diagnosis is being spouted, one inappropriate diagnostic test after another is being performed by people who are wholly unqualified to perform them, all seemingly in a matter of hours. Is this entertaining to people who don't understand medicine? Does the fact that things are happening at lightening speed make them interesting, even if they are completely incomprehensible? I have yet to understand the psychologic complexities involved in the popularity of this show.

All I know is that in the end, Dave Matthews ends up with half of his brain removed, and Dr. House is a heartless lecherous jerk who is STILL addicted to pain killers and everyone else is, once again, surprised by it all. Case closed.

I am very aware that this entry reads like a very nerdy joke, in which I rant about televised medical inaccuracies that no-one else can understand, making my ranting more incomprehensible than the show that I am criticizing. But, ladies and gentleman, my life has turned out to be a series of one very nerdy joke after another. And with this I am entirely comfortbale.

Categories

14 Comments

Maureen said:

I haven't seen House, but find myself glued to the 'boob' for Gray's Anatomy, which has similar staffing problems. I, for one, am planning on practicing as a neonatologist/ perinatologist/ obstetrician/ pediatric surgeon who trains surgical interns. At least I hope to wake up tomorrow to an email that tells me that I matched!

Kevin said:

for me the appeal would be watching dave matthews get his skull drilled. payback is a bitch, dave!

ritchey said:

this is EXACTLY how I used to feel when I watched "Heathcliff."

Sarah said:

Ha! That exact episode made me hop around and yell at the TV too!

Specifically:

1) When he couldn't talk after his surgery they said something like, "well, the language center is in the right brain, and since that's what we removed..." ? Language center? Right brain? Excuse me? How hard is it to fact check that one?

2) He was smiling and dressing himself immediately after waking up from having half of his brain removed. Right. Very realistic.

Mikey said:

John and I started watching this and I don't think we made it to the first commercial break. And then John deleted it from the DVR. And I was fine with that. Terrible television.

J_John said:

I thought I was doing you a favour by deleting it, but it turns out the forces at work conspired against better judgement, and you watched it on your own accord.

However, I'm glad you were able to express your outrage. I have been having fun with the way internet technology has been portrayed in the motion picture industry, and it has proved to be quite useful therapy.

Maria said:

Hello! I really enjoy reading your blog, it's great to hear your take on med school. A few of my fellow pre-meds get together every week to watch House, and I totally agree with your opinion of worst show ever. I think that it is really giving pre-med students the WRONG idea about what being a doctor is like.

I hope you get your first choice with the residency match! Good luck!

fifi said:

Is "House " the one with Hugh Laurie as the eponymous star? He's someone best known previously as Rowan Atkinson's or Stephen Fry's sidekick in various very funny UK comedy programmes.I'm slightly disappointed that he has succumbed to the Dark Side of television. Good luck with the residency.

Alia said:

i felt the same when i first watched house...but because i still didn't start clinical practise i first found it joyfull to sit & watch..but now i realize that truely it's totally unrealistic..how can one doctor do everything at the same time!

Charlie G. said:

I would have to agree and disagree. I like some of the aspects of house but as nyou point out the plot is flakey and their expertice in the medical world seems very over rated. as I have seen a handfull if episodes including the Dave Mathews episode which I could not understand anything in I would say that House is a how about a drug adict doctor with not a care in the world and the brai of a super geneious. This seems like it would make a better Comic.

wouldnt you said:

this post translated:

"Blah blah blah, i don't get laid."

me said:

its a tv show if you want to watch reality go watch the history channel or animal planet

housefanboy472 said:

its kinda funny that you med-folks wont ever be able to enjoy medical drama couse your superiour knowledge of medicine wont allow you to emerge in the drama part =) haha! watch the show about the math guy solving crime, might enjoy it more. btw, im a civil engineer, nobody even bothers to write anything about my profession :'[

Leave a comment

About this Entry

This page contains a single entry by published on March 11, 2007 5:13 PM.

Best memory contest was the previous entry in this blog.

The Match, Part 1 - Introduction is the next entry in this blog.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.